Top Picks & Reviews: The Best Outdoor Plus Fire Pits for Your Lake House

Picture this: A golden sunset reflects off the water, the crisp evening air rolls in, and a fire gently crackles as you gather with friends and family to unwind. A fire pit is more than just a heat source—it’s the heart of your outdoor space. And it has the power to transform your lake house into a retreat for relaxation.

But with so many options, how do you choose the perfect fire pit?

To help, we’ve collected real customer reviews and curated a list of the best Outdoor Plus fire pits, known for their durability, high-end, American-made craftsmanship, and striking designs. Whether you’re drawn to sleek modern lines or rustic charm, there’s a fire feature here to elevate your lakeside backyard to luxury.

How to Choose the Right Fire Pit for Your Lake House

Before we dive into the top picks, let’s review some key questions to help you choose the best fire pit for your lake house.

Fuel Type: Propane vs. Natural Gas

Choosing between propane and natural gas is a key decision. Propane offers flexibility and portability, while natural gas provides a continuous fuel source without the need for refills. Not sure which is best for you? Read our in-depth comparison: Propane Fire Pit vs Natural Gas Fire Pit: Which is Better For Me?

Material Matters: GFRC vs. Concrete vs. Stainless Steel

How long you'll be able to enjoy your fire pit depends on its material. GFRC (Glass Fiber Reinforced Concrete) is lightweight yet incredibly strong and resistant to cracks and weather damage. While stainless steel offers a sleek, modern look with excellent longevity. Find out which material is the best choice for your backyard in our breakdown: GFRC vs Concrete vs Stainless Steel Fire Pits: Only 1 Winner

Ignition Systems: Match Lit vs. Electronic

Many fire pits offer the choice between match-lit ignitions and electronic starters for push-button convenience. Check out our guide on fire pit ignition types to learn the difference between these starter options: Best Fire Pit Ignition for Your Backyard: How to Start a Gas Fire Pit

The Best Outdoor Plus Fire Pits for Your Lake House

Each of these fire pits brings something unique to the table—whether it's modern aesthetics, rustic charm, or maximum heat output. Here’s our expert selection, complete with real customer reviews.

1. Del Mar Fire Pit – Sleek & Modern

Why You’ll Love It:

• Contemporary rectangular shape for a refined look

• Crafted from premium GFRC concrete for durability

• Up to 65,000 BTUs of heat

• Available in multiple color finishes to match your decor

Best For: Modern, minimalist lakefront patios

🔥 Real Review: “The Del Mar Fire Pit is the perfect centerpiece. The sleek design looks striking, and the heat output is just right for chilly nights by the lake.” – Emily R.

Shop the Del Mar Fire Pit Now

2. Coronado Fire Pit – Spanish Elegance Meets Function

Why You’ll Love It:

• Classic rectangular fire pit with a steel powder-coated finish

• Adjustable heat output from 40,000 to 100,000 BTUs

• Seven elegant color options

• Weather-resistant, made in the USA

Best For: Traditional or Mediterranean-style lake homes

🔥 Real Review: “The Coronado Fire Pit is stunning. It adds so much warmth and ambiance to our patio.” – Jason T.

Explore Coronado Fire Pit Options

3. Wood Grain Coronado Fire Pit – Rustic Charm with Modern Performance

Why You’ll Love It:

• Handcrafted GFRC concrete with a realistic wood grain texture

• Up to 160,000 BTUs for powerful warmth

• Resistant to cracking, rust, and weather damage

• Available in three unique wood grain finishes

Best For: Cozy, rustic lakefront aesthetics

🔥 Real Review: “We wanted a fire pit that looked like real wood but could handle the elements—this one is perfect. The texture gets so many compliments. And it heats up fast.” – Sarah M.

Get Your Wood Grain Coronado Fire Pit Today

4. Unity Fire Pit – The Ultimate Social Gathering Spot

Why You’ll Love It:

• Round design promotes conversation and connection

• Massive heat output of up to 190,000 BTUs

• Features an access door for hidden propane tank storage

• Seven striking color options

Best For: Large lake house gatherings and entertaining

🔥 Real Review: “This fire pit is the heart of our backyard. Everyone loves gathering at our house now—it’s where our best memories happen!” – Tom W.

Shop the Unity Fire Pit

5. Sedona Fire Pit – Elegant Simplicity with a Natural Touch

Why You’ll Love It:

• Unique half-moon shape for a refined, organic look

• Lightweight yet incredibly strong GFRC concrete build

• Available in 18 custom colors

• 65,000 BTUs provide just the right amount of warmth

Best For: Modern and organic lake house styles

🔥 Real Review: “The Sedona Fire Pit is a conversation starter. The curved design makes it unique, and it blends beautifully with our natural landscape.” – Jessica L.

Discover the Sedona Fire Pit

Pro Tips for Maximizing Your Fire Pit Experience

A fire pit is more than just a stunning focal point—it’s an investment in comfort, ambiance, and unforgettable gatherings. To ensure you get the most out of your fire feature, a little planning and maintenance go a long way. Here’s how to create a seamless, year-round fire pit experience at your lake house.

Fire Pit Safety & Placement

• Keep your fire pit at least 10 feet away from structures

• Use a wind guard for breezy lakefront locations

• Ensure proper ventilation for propane or natural gas models

Enhance Your Setup with Accessories

• Lava rocks or fire glass for a polished look

• Adirondack chairs or built-in seating for comfort

• Outdoor lighting to complement your fire feature

Year-Round Enjoyment

• Use a protective cover to extend the life of your fire pit

• Add cozy blankets and pillows for fall and winter use

• Pair with a patio heater for extra warmth

Elevate Your Lake House with the Perfect Fire Pit

A fire pit isn’t just a backyard feature—it’s an experience. It turns your lake house into a true retreat, where moments around the fire become lasting memories. Whether you prefer modern minimalism, rustic charm, or a social-centered design, there’s an Outdoor Plus fire pit that’s perfect for you.

Still not sure which fire pit to choose? Our expert buying guide breaks it all down to help you make the best choice: Flame On! The Outdoor Plus Lake House Fire Pit Buying Guide.

Or, reach out to our friendly customer service team. We’d be happy to answer any questions you have. Just drop us a line at sales@lakehouseandcottage.com or call us at 854-777-0909 Mon-Fri 9a-5p CST with all your The Outdoor Plus and fire pit questions.

Find your perfect fire pit today and start creating unforgettable moments by the lake!